PDA

View Full Version : DR. PHIL Anti-HomeSchool Show is on TODAY!


JenniferErix
11-24-2006, 03:46 PM
On in about 20 mintues, here.
(Some cities run it at different times)

4PM Eastern
3PM central

NBC (Whatever local channel that is for you.)
Dr. Phil

I will watch, because I want to be able to form my own oppinions about it.

Just posting this to help remind anyone who wishes to see it as well.

I will record it, if you want to see it, but you will need high speed internet to view it. Just let me know and I will send it to you.

Peace!

Ohio Mom
11-24-2006, 04:01 PM
Thanks for the reminder. I was watching Rachel Ray and will turn it to Dr. Phil in about 10 min. Thanks again

rhassinger
11-24-2006, 04:21 PM
I wouldn't mind reading a summary after it's done. (The TV is rarely used at our house, and when it is it's either playing educational DVDs or it's tuned to PBS.)

JenniferErix
11-24-2006, 05:09 PM
I will write my personal review in a bit. I need to recover after loosing my voice from screaming at the TV.......


P.S. I did record it, though.....

TxSandMom
11-24-2006, 05:58 PM
Deleted

JenniferErix
11-24-2006, 06:34 PM
Dunno. I honestly think they reacted to the outcry against the show. (Not the topic, but the one-sidedness of it) and "Hid" the show on a day when folks were most likely, shopping, sleeping, eating or watching, as your were, football. You know?

I did record it and will have the show in sections ready in a bit. This way if you want to see it, you can see it yourself and make up your own mind, of course.

I came away not feeling like it was an all out atack. It felt more like I was watching mostly publicly educated people talk about homeschooling while not really learning anything about it. I also think this will probably fall right of the radar and drop off.

Other wise, it would have been shown on a monday and not a basic holiday.

Syele
11-24-2006, 08:51 PM
I'd like to see it Jen I didn't see this till too late. I can't wait to get internet at my own house!

MonkeyMamma
11-24-2006, 10:33 PM
I came away not feeling like it was an all out atack. It felt more like I was watching mostly publicly educated people talk about homeschooling while not really learning anything about it. I also think this will probably fall right of the radar and drop off.

Okay so I got home from my parents just in time to see the last 30 mins or so and I have to agree. It wasn't positive at all but it wasn't quite as bad as what I was expecting. My husband and I were both screaming at the TV!! I am so thankful my husband is supportive - actually things like this reinforce the fact that we are doing the right thing.

kristen1nv
11-25-2006, 01:44 AM
I had mixed feelings about several things that they said. I agreed with some of what they said but disagreed with some of what they said. They did of course compare the extremes but I think someone stated here that they anticipated that. At first it was almost presented as if that was the only way to homeschool but then it was clarified a little bit. There were varying POV's on it. At the end his recap was suprising to say the least. I got upset a few times but that was to be expected.

JenniferErix
11-25-2006, 12:59 PM
I have the show recorded and broken into 7 parts. I am having difficulty posting them. But I am working on it.

However, I have a nephews B-Day party to attend today. So, please give me some time, and I will have this up for you.

I still find it hard to believe that a man with a BA an MA and a PHd in Clinical Phsycology could not find (Or was too lazy to research) the truth about modren day homeschooling options and realities. That made me question his credentials, but more so, his motives. KWIM?

Also, it is a hard fact of life that MOST people of MEANS do NOT send their children to Public School. Anymore than they would be caught in a Public Restroon. In fact many people that I have met, who home educate, do so because the public schools are not good enough, but they cannot afford affluent prep schools... (Only 33% of Home Educators site religion as the main factor. :HSLDA (http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200410250.asp))

Interesting fact....
Dr Phil went to school when kids looked like the BEAVER. And his children went to PREP SCHOOL. So I feel his views of Public School are a bit skewed, to say the least. How can he possibly comment on the conditions that inner city kids have to deal with?

A quote from his web site: "Jay, (His oldest son) after scoring two touchdowns in the 8th grade at Cisterian Prep School." Yea, Prep School!


Off to wrap a present!

vantage
11-25-2006, 01:05 PM
I went to the Dr. Phil website just now. They dont stream the show, or at least I did not find it. I did watch his "uncencored" video clip on the subject.

It seemed that he is lumping all homeschoolers in with unschoolers. He then jumps from the idea of having schooling and the structure it brings to the idea of having to job candidates in front of him, one with a college degree and the other without.

He then goes on and then seemingly contradicts himeself by stating that education is not as nearly as great a predictor of success as high intellegence.

Does this mean that an unschooled kid with a high IQ has a better chance than the PS educated student with an IQ that falls near median.

Overall, it seems that the show was put together to touch nerves.

I am not real big on the unschooling idea as it is presented in its most extreme form. I do feel that all teaching methods of various subjects can be complemented by allowing some student lead learning. AFterall why would one want to stop a kid that was on a roll and really starting to "get it" simply for the sake of discipline and structure.

In the real world, if one gets a job that is at least somewhat above entry level, there will be times when one really digs in and pulls an all nighter or pushes aside other tasks to accomplish another. Is this not similar to student lead learning jags. It seems that often this type of flexibility is an indication you are in a "better" job, or have earned the right to work unsupervised due to talent and competency.

Overall it seems that the program was put together so as to press on the nerves of hsers, and validate those who do not.

JenniferErix
11-25-2006, 01:14 PM
Apparently, he missed all of the "RESEARCH" that states that most colleges not only welcome homeschoolers, but actively recruit them (http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000002/00000241.asp), because they are the students that have proven that they can deal with conflict, work well with others, self-motivate and turn items in on time... (Those were his reasons for saying that he would likely not hire the homeschoolers verses the college graduate.)

But again, why does he compare apples to oranges? Why can't a homschooler also be a college graduate?

He is soooooo mistaken, and ignorant of the current truths of children whose parents choose to privately direct the education of their children. << (That's my feable attempt at talking about all forms of homeschooling in one shot! hahaha!)

Ok ok ok I know.. I am leaving now....



(Above link directs you to an article.. the article states: In 2006, the overwhelming majority of colleges and universities now have either a dedicated homeschool admissions officer or a homeschool admissions policy. In fact, since many colleges have experienced the quality of homeschoolers they often actively pursue homeschooled students.)

AmyU
11-25-2006, 11:58 PM
I didn't get to watch it and I really wanted to. Football was on here instead.

Jeannie Davis
11-26-2006, 10:22 PM
Jennifer, did you manage to get the show recorded and posted. I forgot all about it and I REALLY wanted to see it. We only had that day to rake and burn leaves. ARGH! Let me know if you have it streamed yet so I can download them.

Jeannie

JenniferErix
11-27-2006, 01:27 AM
Hey there.

I am working on it, hon. SOrry. I recorded them on the computer at too high of quality and it means the files (7 of them) are taking forever to process. Plus, they are too large to post through you tube. SO I am trying to cut them all in two...

I have not forgotten!
hahaha!

AmyU
11-27-2006, 10:04 AM
thanks Jen, waiting patiently here.

kachelsi
11-27-2006, 05:02 PM
Here is the link i found for anyone that would like to dispute what was said on the Dr. Phil show and bring their opinion on homeschool to light. It is asking for people who think homeschooling is the way to go and would like to be on the show. I hope I got that info straight if I dont its in the link http://www.drphil.com/plugger/respond/?plugID=10527

TeacherMom
11-28-2006, 10:09 AM
I watched the show because of hearing about it in here someplace. I found that it leaned towards not a good idea but it focused on UNschooling as seperate from Home schooling in traditions. I think it actually showed some good situations in homeschooling itself.... Of course the people in the audience that they chose were not your typical people either.
I hope I don't offend anyone here when I say I don't do my schooling that way, unschooling. I teach as a teacher would, as that is what my calling is. Even my hubby said to me last night after listening to me talk about the kids I am subbing with this month, "You are a teacher, listen to you!" I felt like DUH YA? What have I been doing all my life here? Lol. But back to the focus of the program, I think the media portrays home school as they see it.
Too many of us allow it to be a certain amount of people and type of people showing off as home schoolers and I think the majority of us are homeschooling in our own traditionalized walys.
I think this because when we are asked about our schedules , we actualy can come up with them.
When we are asked about what we use to teach, we know what we are teaching our children, what subject we are focused the most on at any given time.
Those are the things that we need to get out there to the main stream. Don't ya think?

Jackie
11-28-2006, 12:18 PM
Yes, I think you're right in many ways. I think most of us have a schedule of some kind. Whether we actually STICK to it is another matter, lol, but I never stuck to my plans when I was in the classroom either! At the same time, I don't think any of us here that don't "unschool" would look down on families that did. We need to stand by their right to educate their children as THEY see fit.

As far as sending a reply, there's no way I would. I would under no circumstances be willing to appear on the show, especially after hearing the manipulation that went on the first time. I do not believe that Dr. Phil would give homeschoolers the opportunity to present a fair representation.

kachelsi
11-28-2006, 03:09 PM
I have no desire to reply or go on the show either, but didnt know if someone here would like to. I just feel so blessed to have the right to home school my dd. I know the Lord laid homeschool on my heart and this is His plan for my family. I am also very grateful and blessed that I dont have to explain to the media public or anyone else why I homeschool, what method I choose etc.. etc.. I follow the laws for my state and I do not worry what tom, jane, joe, whoever thinks about my decision I do not have to answer to them. I do not feel the need to debate for people to agree with my decision to homeschool because what is good for my house may not be for theirs. It is easier for me to remeber who I answer to and who holds me accountable and that is my Jesus.

TeacherMom
11-28-2006, 07:29 PM
The only thing that worried me after watching the show on TV was that Dr Phill said if anyone does not like the idea of how easy it is for these people to teach thier children thier own way that they needed to get busy and form some stronger laws because what we do to teach our kids is legal.
That part made me worry for some peoples here in California might make dumb laws to make it harder to school in the fashion we see fit.
I too am so grateful that we can teach our kids how ever we want to.
For the little I know of Un schooling, I am curious about it because what I thought it was more like learning by doing things, like shopping and feild trips for science, and math and reading a lot and writing your own stories and stuff like that.... more or less relaxed learning styles but still teaching. The way Dr Phils show made it sound its more telling the kids to go do whatever each day and if you learn something good going kid?
Someone tell me how it really is?

DanielsMom
11-29-2006, 01:37 AM
It seemed that he is lumping all homeschoolers in with unschoolers. He then jumps from the idea of having schooling and the structure it brings to the idea of having to job candidates in front of him, one with a college degree and the other without.


.

The "structured" school/job advantage is a joke to me. I have a friend that thinks this way. I tend to think more along the lines of who gets off work every summer? And long holidays, and in-service days, spring break, early dismissals...???

TeacherMom
11-29-2006, 09:07 AM
"privately direct the education of their children. << "

WOW Jen I think you summed up homeschooling in one sentence there very well!
That really is it! How cool!
I think you stated it in such an intellegent sounding statement that even Dr. Phil would have a hard time arguing it heheh!
Good job!

JenniferErix
11-29-2006, 11:06 AM
Oh! Thank you! That is very nice of you to say.

This comment came about because I needed to find a way to succinctly explain why I homeschool, to those outside of the lifestyle, so to speak. Plus, I am the only homeschooler in both mine and my DH family, I have to explain things all the time....

Texas has the ultimate freedom, in regards to HSing. This is because we can homeschool traditional, we can hire tutors, and sign up for classes.. any combination thereof... And I am not always the "Teacher" and they are not always "At Home".... no limits and no requirements.... freedom!

So, I "Privately Direct the Education of My children."

God bless Texas!

Anyway, so that is where it came from.
Thanks for the compliment.
I think I will change my signature.....

JenniferErix
11-30-2006, 02:43 AM
Guys, I don't know if aI am ever going to be able to get this stupid recording transfered to a playable format. It is stuck in giga-pocket format and they are HUUUUGE in size...

I am a dork...
Oh well....

I will keep trying though..
Sorry.
I though it would be cool to record it and share, but I can't get it to work, yet.

TeacherMom
11-30-2006, 08:42 AM
cool, no you are not one of those .. keep trying! Just keep trying trying trying.... Nemo is one of our encouragers in home schooling here!
you know, the fish that kept saying just keep swimming swimming swimming....
By the way, Can I use your quote if I write an article on Homeschooling some day?

Deena
11-30-2006, 01:34 PM
Washington is that way too---I am so glad, and very grateful for the freedoms that we have!!!